If your North Carolina homeowners premium has climbed noticeably since 2024, it is not your imagination and it is probably not your house.
Base rates went up 7.5% on 1 June 2025, and another 7.5% on 1 June 2026. That is roughly 15% compounded over two years, applied across the state.
How it happened
In January 2024 the North Carolina Rate Bureau — the body that represents property insurers in the state, separate from the Department of Insurance — filed for a 42.2% average increase.
Insurance Commissioner Mike Causey rejected it. That triggered a formal hearing that ran for weeks with witnesses and evidence on both sides. The Department's own witnesses argued rates should either fall or rise by less than 3%.
The two sides settled at roughly 15% over two years, split into the two increases above.
42.2% → 15%
What the Rate Bureau asked for, against what was agreed. The settlement also barred them from filing again before 1 June 2027.
It did not land evenly
The increase was applied by territory, not as a flat statewide figure.
Coastal counties took the most. Carteret through Brunswick saw around 16% in 2025 and 15.9% in 2026. New Hanover, Dare and Columbus are in similar territory.
Charlotte saw 9.3% then 9.2% — the highest of the major inland metros.
Raleigh and Durham saw 7.5% in each year.
The mountains took the least. Buncombe, Watauga and Yancey went up 4.4% then 4.5%, reflecting the flooding from Helene rather than hurricane exposure.
What actually drove it
Three things, none of them about individual homeowners.
Storms. Helene in autumn 2024 caused historic flooding in western North Carolina. Before that, Florence in 2018 and Matthew in 2016 hit the east hard. Insurers price the next storm, not the last one.
Rebuilding costs. Materials and labour have risen faster than general inflation. The same house costs more to rebuild than it did five years ago, so the coverage limit rises and the premium follows.
Reinsurance. Insurers buy their own insurance against catastrophic years, and that has become far more expensive globally. It gets passed down.
And there is more coming
The Rate Bureau filed again on 30 October 2025, this time for a statewide overall increase of 68.3% over two years. That is currently working its way through the same process.
Whether it lands anywhere near that figure is another matter — the last one was cut from 42.2% to 15%. But it is worth knowing it is in the system.
What you can actually do
Shop it. The statewide base rate is a starting point, not what any individual carrier charges. Companies file their own deviations from it, and the spread between them on the same house is wider than most people expect.
Check your roof age is recorded correctly. It is the single biggest factor in what you pay, and it gets logged wrongly surprisingly often, especially after a sale.
Ask about wind mitigation credits if you are on the coast. Protective devices, impact-resistant windows and reinforced garage doors all qualify for discounts in coastal North Carolina, and they vary by carrier.
Consider your wind deductible. A higher percentage deductible cuts the annual premium but raises what you pay after a storm. That is a real trade-off worth thinking about rather than accepting the default.
And do not let coverage lapse. A gap, even a short one, makes you more expensive at the next renewal.
Not sure whether you are overpaying?
Answer a few questions and licensed North Carolina agents will come back with real quotes. Free, no obligation, and we cap every request at three agents so you are not buried in calls.
Compare quotes →